Date pinwheels (and their cranberry cousins): A holiday tradition around here

Working side by side with someone over the course of years will teach you a lot about each other. One of the comfortable things about being in the King Arthur test kitchen is the familiar ground of long-time working relationships. It’s come to light over time that PJ and I share the same formative Catholic-school education, history of high school and college jock activity, deep love for the power of the written word, and…dates.

There have been many days in the kitchen when we commiserated over the Rodney Dangerfield treatment this sumptuous fruit receives. We’ve both encountered people who were intrigued at the baked goods we put out, asking, “Oh boy, what’s in it?” The second we mention dates, they turn away, giving it a pass. If you’re in that club, don’t turn away, we have a version for you, too.

To us, dates are comforting, sweet, intense. A fresh Medjool date with a filling of cream cheese and some chopped nuts is one of the nicest things on earth. And at holiday time, it’s just not right unless a batch of Date Pinwheels (or two) gets made. They’re the perfect do-ahead cookie, because they need to be rolled and chilled before slicing. And they can certainly be made up and frozen, up to 2 months in advance.

There are two easy parts to this: the dough and the filling. First the dough:

Cream the butter and brown sugar,

datepinwhlscrm.JPG

Add the eggs, one at a time. Scrape, mix once more,

dpinwhlsaddegg.JPG

Then add the flour, salt and baking soda.

dpnwhladdry.JPG

Put the dough in a large plastic bag, squish it flat, and refrigerate it for at least an hour.

dpnwhlsflattendough.JPG

I’ve been chilling dough this way for years. To me, it makes sense. You’re going to be rolling it out flat anyhow, so why not get a head start? Plus, a thin slab of dough will chill much more quickly than a big round blob in a bowl will. You can get there either way. I just prefer this one.

For the filling, put the dates, sugar, water and salt in a saucepan.

dpnwhlfilling1.JPG

Bring to a boil over medium-high heat, stirring until the sugar dissolves. Reduce the heat and simmer for 15 minutes, stirring occasionally, until the mixture thickens and makes popping sounds as it boils. You should be able to see the bottom of the pot for 5 seconds when you move your stirring weapon across it.

dpnwhlsfillingdone.JPG

Remove from the heat, stir in the nuts, and set aside to cool to room temperature.

dpnwhlfilladdnuts.JPG

If you’d rather try the cranberry filling (I made a double batch of dough, and invented this filling for the non-date-loving population), put all of the cranberry version’s ingredients into a saucepan, cover it, and bring the whole business to a boil.

dpncranfill1.JPG

Once the mixture is boiling, uncover it and stir while it cooks, The berries will pop and the mixture will thicken.

dpnwhlcranfill4.JPG

When you can stir the mixture and see the bottom of the pot for 5 seconds before the filling closes back over, the filling is ready. Take it off the heat, stir in the nuts, and let it cool to room temperature.

Once the dough is chilled enough to roll out, take half of it and place it on a piece of parchment or waxed paper, lightly dusted with flour. When I started rolling the first part of the dough, I found an island of unincorporated brown sugar staring back at me. Time for some quick cosmetic surgery.

dpnwhlsurgery1.JPG

The hole was easily patched with some more dough.

dpnwhlsurgery2.JPG

Roll out the dough into a rectangle 9 x 12 inches, and 1/4-inch thick.

dpnwhlmeasuredough.JPG

Spread half the filling over the dough, covering the entire surface. Use the parchment to help you roll the dough up lengthwise.

dpnwhlsrollup.JPG

If the dough sticks to the paper, tease it off with a floured hand or scraper. After the roll is formed, use the paper to wrap it (this will help support the dough, which is soft).

dpnwhlparchmentroll.JPG

One neat trick to use for chilling is to cut the core from a roll of paper towels lengthwise (or at this time of year, just save those empty wrapping paper rolls, if the kids haven’t destroyed them bopping each other over the head)

dpnwhlscutcore.JPG

and pop the rolled dough into it; the cardboard will help keep the pinwheels round. You can then place the whole thing in a plastic bread bag or wrap in plastic wrap.

dpnstorecore.JPG

Repeat with the remaining dough and filling. Chill the logs for several hours or overnight; you can also freeze the rolls at this point if you’re trying to get ahead. Once the dough is firm enough to slice, take it out of the refrigerator and let it temper for 10 minutes so it doesn’t crack when you slice it. Cut into 1/3-inch slices,

dpnwhlslice.JPG

and place on parchment-lined baking sheets, about 2 inches apart.

dpnwhl2inapart.JPG

Here’s a hint for cutting: to keep the cookies round, give the roll of dough a quarter turn after each slice. That way the pressure of the knife won’t press the cookie down each time. If the dough gets too soft or you forget to turn the roll, you may end up with a slice that looks like this:

dpnwhlflatslice.JPG

No worries. Just put it on the baking sheet and give it a gentle squeeze back into a round shape. The dough is pretty forgiving that way.

dpnwhlsquishround.JPG

Bake for 8 to 10 minutes, until they look like this.

dpnwhldnbkg.JPG

Let them rest on the cookie sheet for a few minutes before transferring them to a rack to cool. Don’t they look gorgeous? They taste even better.

dpnwhlsletseat.JPG

Please read, rate, and tell us what you think of our Date Pinwheels (and their cranberry cousins) here.

I’d love to give you a bake/buy price comparison, but as far as I can discern, you can’t buy a Date Pinwheel for love nor money, at least online. For those of you who like to know these things, the recipe costs out at 15 cents per cookie, which is a pretty good deal no matter how you slice it!

Susan Reid
About

Susan Reid grew up in New Jersey, graduated from Bates College and the Culinary Institute of America, and is presently enjoying her fourth career after stints in advertising, running restaurants, and teaching at the New England Culinary Institute. She joined King Arthur in 2002 to ...

comments

  1. Manderley

    Can this be done with dried dates or dried cranberries? Snowbound here and we have them dried but not fresh.
    Yes, both will work; not to worry. I used dried dates for the filling anyway. Craisins will also do fine. Susan

    Reply
  2. Alvara

    They look wonderful! I wish I could reach into my computer and grab one, or maybe both. It would be hard to figure out which one I would want to eat first.
    I have dates in the house so I guess the dates win. Thanks for another wonderful recipe. Happy New Year

    Reply
  3. Charlene S.

    Would this recipe work if I substitute 1 cup of whole wheat flour for one cup of the all purpose flour? Looks wonderful!

    Give it a try, Charlene. Might be a bit trickier to roll out. Try white whole wheat, for the improved flavor. PJH

    Reply
  4. Debj

    OMG! These are a ‘must make’! I only had some wonderful dried apricots in the house so substituted them for the dates… fantastic. Very easy but a little time consuming.. chilling, rolling, filling, chilling, slicing and baking. But, I can see how they would easily adapt to your own time schedule. I just wanted them *today*… and they are just now baking. Yummy! Thanks for the recipe!!
    You’re most welcome. You’re right, it’s a bit of a handful all in one go, but it’s great fun to have a roll or two in the freezer for when the urge strikes….Susan

    Reply
  5. Nicki

    Would you say these are more crunchy or chewy?
    A little of both, actually. The outside gets a bit of crunch, while the insides stay bendy. You can make them crunchier with a few more minutes in the oven, if you’re so inclined. Susan

    Reply
  6. Julie

    I used to give people the “date look” you mention. But when I went to visit my husband’s family in Malta and was given things that tasted WONDERFUL and then they told me they were filled with dates – I became an instant fan. Will have to add these to my list.

    Reply
  7. Andrea

    So, I’ve made rugelach, spritz, kipfel cookies, Tre Colore, biscotti, gingerbread men, and even sugar cookies…but cooky baking is never complete until I make date pinwheels.

    My husband eyed them rather suspiciously as I fussed a bit over them earlier today – I am a HORRIBLE rolled cooky baker, and if they’re not sugar cookies or peanut butter cookies, he’s skeptical anyway. Mine always turn out mishappen and well, rectangular. As the first batch cooled, I watched him sidle over to them, and pop one (whole, I think, to as not give away that he tried one) into his mouth. Chew, chew, chew…He grabbed 6 and ran off to the office to eat in peace since my 16 month old was begging for his own. Score!

    So we made a batch without the nuts, a batch with, and they’re all gone, already. And there’s only 2 1/2 people in our home! I guess I’ll have to make more tomorrow… ;) As well as some date-nut bread, and more rugelach, with dates, of course. :)

    Reply
  8. Nancy

    I like the idea of using the paper towel rolls. My last batch of log dough cookies were decidedly square. That’s what I like the best about this blog -the little tricks that make things turn out better.

    Reply
  9. Patty

    This is the same as my grandmother’s recipe!! My mother and I have made these for years. There is also a chocolate coconut filling but it’s not nearly as good as the dates.

    Reply
  10. Susan

    Thanks for the recipe and humorous yet helpful tidbits like what kids naturally do with cardboard rolls–ha ha! This cookie is a tradition in my family, my grandma and mother made them more cake-like and did not roll them, but dolloped the filling on a dollop of dough then another little tsp of dough on top of filling. My daughter calls them Jewish Cookies because of the dates, and my mother’s heritage. Thanks for the cranberry edition, now I know what to do with fresh cranberries besides floating them in bowls with candles or making cranberry relish no one eats! I like the rolled wheel version better-more even distribution of date filling , and looks so much better! Love the blog and love King Arthur Flour- I’m a devoted customer!

    Reply

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *