Emerald Isle Pistachio Cupcakes: march gladness

IMG_0353

St. Patrick’s Day is just over 1 month from today. What’s on your green radar this year?

When you think St. Pat’s, you might think corned beef and cabbage. Or maybe Irish soda bread – American style, or traditional.

If you’re lucky enough to know about Chocolate Stout Cake – the biggest, densest, most brazenly decadent dark chocolate layer cake ever – you definitely think about that, raising a glass of Guinness in its honor.

There’s just one problem with all of these treats: they’re not green. And there are those among you (you know who you are) who can’t let St. Pat’s Day pass without baking something green: shortbread, muffins, cookies, maybe a bright-green lime cake.

Unless you’re going the food color route (in which case green baking can assume any flavor), lime and pistachio are the flavors of the day. And even those “green” flavors won’t yield the bright-green treats you’re determined to bring to the office. For that, you need (dare I say it?) pudding mix, or Jell-O.

Which is what you’ll find, in both cake and icing, in these green pistachio cupcakes.

If you’re opposed to using boxed mixes of any kind, including pudding, then get off the train right here – it’s not destined for any station at which you’d care to disembark.

But if you’re a relaxed kind of baker – like me – read on. Here’s another recipe to add to your green St. Pat’s collection.

Preheat the oven to 350°F. Lightly grease the wells of a standard muffin pan; or line the pan with muffin  papers, and grease the papers (for best release).

In a medium-sized mixing bowl, beat together the following until thoroughly combined:

3/4 cup granulated sugar
1/2 cup vegetable oil
2 large eggs
1/4 teaspoon pistachio flavor, optional; for enhanced flavor
3/4 teaspoon salt
2 teaspoons baking powder
1/2 teaspoon baking soda

In a separate small bowl, whisk together the following:

1 2/3 cups (7 ounces) King Arthur Unbleached All-Purpose Flour
3 1/8-ounce package instant pistachio pudding mix or 1-ounce package sugar-free pudding mix*
2 tablespoons cake enhancer, optional; for increased moistness

*Use a national brand, for deepest green color.

In another bowl, whisk together 1/2 cup plain or vanilla yogurt (or sour cream); and 1/2 cup milk.

Starting and ending with the flour mixture, alternately beat in the flour and yogurt/milk, as follows: 1/3 of the flour, half the yogurt/milk, 1/3 of the flour, the remaining yogurt/milk, and the remaining flour. Beat gently to combine after each addition. Scrape the bottom and sides of the bowl, and beat briefly.

Stir in 3/4 cup shelled, chopped pistachios, if desired. This is for those of you who’d feel odd making pistachio cupcakes that didn’t actually include any pistachios. Personally, I prefer the cupcakes without the chopped nuts, but each to his own.

Spoon the batter into the wells of the pan; a muffin scoop is the ideal tool here.

The wells will be about 3/4 full.

Bake the cupcakes for 18 to 22 minutes, until they appear set and a toothpick inserted into the middle of one of the center cupcakes comes out clean.

Remove the cupcakes from the oven.

As soon as you can handle them, transfer them to a rack to cool.

Now for the icing. You can actually make this before the cupcakes, since it has to chill for awhile; but if you’re not in a hurry, afterwards is fine, too.

Combine the following in a microwave-safe bowl or saucepan:

1 cup heavy or whipping cream*
1/2 cup milk*
4 1/2 cups mini-marshmallows (3/4 standard-size bag)
3 1/8-ounce package instant pistachio pudding mix or 1-ounce package sugar-free pudding mix
1/3 cup confectioners’ sugar
1/8 teaspoon pistachio flavor, optional; for enhanced flavor

*To make icing stiff enough to pipe and hold its shape, substitute 1/2 cup heavy cream for the 1/2 cup milk. If you’re not going to pipe the frosting, prepare the recipe as written.

Heat everything gently, stirring often, until the marshmallows have melted and the mixture is smooth. Remove from the heat, and chill until completely cold.

Using a stand mixer or electric hand mixer, whip the frosting until it’s smooth and creamy. If you’ve used all cream, it’ll be quite stiff, which makes it perfect for piping.

Spread the icing (or pipe the all-cream version) atop the cupcakes. If you pipe it, you probably won’t need the optional garnish of chopped nuts; if you spread the icing, chopped nuts help dress the cakes up.

Now, one word about this icing: its consistency is noticeably “marshmallow-y.” Think Hostess Sno Ball. If you’re not a fan of this type of frosting, try Italian Buttercream, flavored with pistachio flavor or enhanced with pistachio paste.

Now THAT’S green!

Read, bake, and review (please) our recipe for Emerald Isle Pistachio Cupcakes.

Print just the recipe.

PJ Hamel
About

PJ Hamel was born in Wisconsin, grew up in New England, and graduated from Brown University. She was a journalist in Massachusetts and Maine before joining the King Arthur Flour Company in 1990, where she's been ever since. Author or co-author of three King Arthur ...

comments

  1. LucyLu24

    These look wonderful! I am very eager to bake green cupcakes this March. And pistachio is such an underrated flavor in my opinion, I hope many will be inspired to use the great flavor in many applications this spring!

    Have fun! They’re pretty tasty. For enhanced flavor, it’s worth getting the pistachio flavor; although a touch of almond flavor helps, too… Enjoy – PJH

    Reply
  2. narfing

    I tried the king cake cupcakes and they didn’t dome up. These are pretty and domed on top, too. I checked my oven temp and it is accurate. I never open the oven door. Any other ideas?

    Decorating tip: Try the A1 Wilton tip for frosting. So pretty!

    Gentle Cupcake Baker – Be sure not to overmix the batter and only fill the cups 3/4 full. The batter needs someplace to go so it can dome. If these theories don’t apply – be sure to call our baker’s hotline and we’ll trouble shoot with you (855-371-2253). Irene @ KAF

    Reply
  3. cartvl219

    The use of the Pistachio Pudding Mix is reminiscent of the St. Pat’s Pistachio Cookies. But this year I think I’ll make the Irish Cream Cupcakes. If I make only a half recipe of the Italian Buttercream I shouldn’t have too much left over.

    Yes, same concept. Have fun with the Irish Cream cupcakes – they’re definitely “rated R” for ridiculously good! PJH

    Reply
  4. carol1lynn

    Last year I tried the Guiness Stout chocolate cake. Loved it. Can’t wait to try these cupcakes. In the past I have made “Watergate Cake”. Which is similar with the pistachio pudding. One of my family favorites.

    Why not bake up both for a balance of deep, rich chocolate and zippy, nutty pistachio cupcakes? Glad you’re trying our recipes out and letting us know how they do! Kim@KAF

    Reply
  5. jms2

    I made these cupcakes today. Sooooo delicious. My icing didn’t stand up for piping but I know I was a tad over on the cream and a tad under on the sugar. I’ll try it again before St. Pat’s Day. So fun making something green that isn’t a vegetable. Thanks for a great recipe.

    Reply
  6. brown114

    These are very cute. How would the cupcake be different if I used cake flour instead?

    This recipe was tried and tested and found to work best using the all purpose flour. Using cake flour will result in a more tender cupcake and may not hold up those pistachios in the cupcake – Irene@KAF

    Reply
  7. ssuch535558

    What kind of yogurt low-fat, fat-free, Greek? I think leaving out the nuts in the cupcakes and sprinkle the icing w/ them would be fun.

    Plain, not Greek; Greek is so thick that it alters the liquid/flour balance. And low-fat or regular would make a more tender cupcake than fat-free, for sure. Enjoy (are you allowed to enjoy these during Lent??) :) PJH

    Reply
  8. sadeyeleader

    OK, I made the cupcakes, they were fine, but the frosting is so wrong. I didn’t have mini marshmallows so I used regular size and the weight version. I was wondering if the regular could have gone wrong or what? I followed the instructions otherwise. I will have to resort to buttercream but I would like to know how you think I went wrong.

    It is hard to say what may have happened without knowing a little more about what went wrong, feel free to call our baker’s hotline so we can figure out what may have happened!-Jon 855-371-2253

    Reply
    1. Eddie

      Hi folks,

      I make my frosting using cream cheese (8 ounces), softened butter (5 TBSP) some pistachio pudding 4-6 ounces, some almond extract 1/4 to 1/3 teaspoon and some powdered sugar (3 cups). Add a few drops of green food coloring .It works really well on these cupcakes.

    2. PJ Hamel , post author

      Eddie, thanks so much for sharing your recipe. I’m definitely trying this sometime. Love the touch of almond, as well as the pudding. I’ve really enjoyed using pudding mix in cake, icing, cookies… maybe I’ll try it in muffins next! PJH

  9. Nutrilisa

    I made these today, and they came out nice, but the frosting was not good. The frosting did not set up. The frosting was ok to taste but had a destinct chalky texture. I believe this is due to the pistachio instant pudding. The pudding mix has small pieces of pistachio and clogged up the star tip when piping. Perhaps there is another way to prepare the frosting? Thanks

    Sorry it wasn’t your cup of tea. I’d suggest you make another type of frosting; not everyone is a fan of this one, which is akin to the marshmallow-y coating on a Hostess Sno-ball. You might find the pistachio buttercream on our Pistachio Cupcakes more to your liking – give it a try, let us know what you think. PJH

    Reply
  10. dmbaking

    I’m planning on making these cupcakes today and I’m making sure I have all necesary documents; but I’m confused about the amount of pudding mix I should be using. Am I supposed to use 3 1/8 oz total weight of pudding mix. Or 3 packages of 1/8 oz of pudding mix? The packages of pudding they sell at stores are 1.87oz. Please clarify… I don’t want to under use or over use the pudding mix. Thanks!

    You will need to use a total of 3 1/8th ounces of pudding mix by weight for this recipe!-Jon

    Reply
    1. PJ Hamel , post author

      Check out the directions in the blog post, Nikki – there’s one box in the cupcakes, one box in the icing. Size of box depends on whether or not you’re using sugar-free, but your 3.4-ounce package (if it’s regular, not sugar-free), should be just fine. PJH

  11. rochelle_keefer

    Eating one of these right now! Great recipe. I would leave the extra pistachios out next time. The flavor is enough from the pudding mix and I didn’t like the added texture of them. I should have read all these reviews before I made them though. I used Greek yogurt. The middles sank after they baked. I’m assuming that’s why. I never buy regular yogurt though. Could I use it, but just use less/more milk? After I put all that delicious marshmallow-y pistachio goodness on top, you couldn’t tell they were ugly anyway! I really love the frosting. I want to try it with other pudding mixes now!
    Try using about 1 tablespoon less if you are using Greek yogurt. You may need to play with it a little bit, but it sounds like you have good plans for making more. ~ MaryJane

    Reply
  12. Dessert By Candy

    Great recipe that foregoes the dreaded cake mix. Added 2oz melted dark chocolate to 1/4 of the batter to make marble cakes. I made it into 6 bundtlettes with extra batter to spare for some extra treats for the baker. A bit of cream cheese pistachio glaze is my alternative to frosting. Everyone loved it on St Patrick’s Day!
    Sounds so lovely, bet the glaze was amazing! ~ MaryJane

    Reply
  13. dinchas

    I agree the icing is a mess. It is now sliding off my cup cakes. I guess that is why you said to sprinkle the nuts on top if you didn’t pipe it to make it look better. Next time I think I will get some Dream Whip and make my old Watergate Cake icing. It always turned out perfect. The cake part is really fine, but never again on the icing!

    If the icing slid off, it’s because the cupcakes had residual heat that melted it. Be sure the cupcakes are completely cool (resting 2 hours at least) at room temperature before you ice them. Even the slightest trace of heat will do this! Kim@KAF

    Reply
  14. jtee4short

    I rated this recipe 5 stars already but I wanted to add another comment without skewing the ratings. I made these cupcakes for our family St. Patrick’s Day dinner. They’re still talking about those cupcakes!

    Excellent – so glad to hear they were a hit! Not everyone loves that marshmallow-y frosting, but I sure do – and I guess your family feels the same. Thanks for sharing here – PJH

    Reply
  15. JT

    I really enjoy reading your blog posts PJ. I don’t enjoy making cupcakes/muffins as I find filling the tins tedious. I want to make this as a bundt cake for my mother’s birthday.

    Would you recommend trying that? If so, do I double (or triple) the recipe? And what adjustments should I make to the time and temperature?

    I look forward to sharing my experience with all of you.

    Reply
    1. The Baker's Hotline

      We haven’t tried making these cupcakes as a Bundt cake. If you want to experiment, you might try baking a double recipe in a Bundt pan. The cake would likely take about an hour to bake at 350 degrees. I hope your mother has a wonderful birthday.~Jaydl@KAF

  16. JT

    Hi Jaydl,

    Thanks for the tips. I want to share my experience baking this recipe as a Bundt cake. I used Nordic Ware’s Anniversary pan (10-15 cup capacity).

    1) I doubled the recipe and noticed that the batter became extremely thick. The motor of my hand mixer became noticeably slower. As the pudding mix is intended to thicken up, I’m guessing that two packages of pudding mix contributed to this.
    2) The recipe took about 1Hr 20Min. I would check at around 1Hr 15Min.
    3) The cake raised incredibly high. I would say that it was probably half an inch lower than the rim when it was done. When I put the batter into the pan, it only reached half the height of the pan. Now that I’m making my comments, I’ve noticed that PJ’s cupcakes raised nicely and have an attractive “muffin-top”. I’m wondering if this had to do with the pudding mix or the 4 tbsp of baking powder used after the recipe was doubled.
    4) I did not add any pistachio flavouring nor chopped pistachios. As a result, the pistachio flavour wasn’t very pronounced (neither was the green colour). However, the cake was very moist and tasty.
    5) The top 1/6th of the cake (the bottom when inverted) had an interesting crust. It was similar to a crusty bun. However, the crumb throughout the cake was consistently cake-like.

    That said, I was not disappointed with the result and would try this again. I would suggest others try this as a Bundt cake too. As the cake raised very high, I don’t think I would double the recipe. Lastly, I’m wondering how well this recipe would work when substituting other flavours of pudding mix….. hmm, butterscotch anybody? Wow, I wrote a lot. Hopefully others will find these thoughts helpful!

    Reply

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *