In Search Of The Perfect Rustic Loaf

star rating (25) rate this recipe »
Recipe photo

In Search Of The Perfect Rustic Loaf

star rating (25) rate this recipe »
Published prior to 2008

We've all had it at least once. It has a crisp crust, a chewy interior, large, irregular holes and a slight tang. When toasted, it soaks up butter like nobody's business. In short, it's leavened perfection.

French bakers Lionel and Max Poilane have mastered this bread. The rustic bread has become upper crust, but its roots are peasant. Its many names reflect this: rustic bread, farm bread, country bread, pain de campagne and hearty country loaf. Although it requires time, this bread thrives on long periods of "neglect", making it ideal for busy farm (and city) kitchens.

But can this bread be made in the bread machine? We weren't sure until good friend and freelance food writer Marcy Goldman, sent us a recipe she'd developed for her bread machine. After following her formula and tasting her delicious rustic loaf, we concluded that this bread can indeed be made with the help of a bread machine.

Watching friend and local restaurateur Rebecca Cunningham turn out her near-perfect, Poilane-inspired loaves by hand made us even more eager to take up the challenge of making a bread machine version. So, with thanks to Marcy, and after experimenting with different proportions of liquid to flour, as well as alternate rising and baking methods (which you'll find detailed in the notes at the end), here's a loaf the Poilane family would be proud of.

For Large 1 1/2 to 2-pound Machine

The Sponge (begin the night before)
1 cup water, chlorine-free
1/4 teaspoon instant yeast
1 1/4 cups King Arthur Unbleached Special Bread Flour
2 tablespoons King Arthur Traditional Whole Wheat Flour
1 tablespoon yellow cornmeal
1 tablespoon semolina flour

The Dough
1 cup water, chlorine-free
1 tablespoon kosher salt
1 tablespoon granulated sugar
1/4 teaspoon instant yeast
3 1/2 cups King Arthur Unbleached Special Bread Flour

The next day (or about 8 hours later) stir down the sponge. Continue to make the dough. Program your machine for Manual or Dough, and press Start. As the dough begins to mix it should form first a soft mass, then eventually a soft ball that is not too stiff, but not sticky, either. Adjust with additional flour or water as necessary. (If the dough isn't coming together, stop the machine, and stir the dough with a rubber spatula to help the sponge and added ingredients combine. Re-program the machine for Dough, and start it again.)

When the cycle is complete, remove the dough from the machine. (It can hang around for a bit -- you don't have to rush.) Cover with a tea towel and let rest for 30 minutes. (If you want to leave the dough all day, place it in a lightly greased bowl, cover the bowl, and refrigerate it. When you're ready to work with it, deflate if necessary, and allow to warm slightly before proceeding.)

After its rest period, deflate the dough gently and form it into a round ball, Place the ball, seam-side-down, on a cornmeal-dusted baking sheet. Cover it lightly with a tea towel. Let it rise a second time until it's puffy and about 30% to 40% larger, about 1 hour. Don't let it rise too much, since it rises some more in the oven and, if it's overproofed initially, it'll collapse as it bakes.

Preheat the oven to 475°F. Make several 1/4- to 1/2-inch slashes or crosshatches in the loaf. If your dough deflates at this point, it means it rose too much. But even if it does topple a bit or deflate, generally the heat of the oven will help it spring back.

Using a clean plant mister, spritz the loaf with water. Spray some water into the oven, and place the bread on the lowest rack.

Spritz the oven walls every few minutes for the first 15 minutes of baking. Lower the heat to 425°F (this reduction in heat mimics the "falling oven" used by brick-oven bakers, and will give your bread an incredible crust), and continue to bake until well-browned, about 35 minutes. The interior temperature of the bread should register 190°F on an instant-read thermometer. Remove the bread from the oven, and cool it on a wire rack before slicing. Store, cut side down, on a counter (do not cover). Yes, this really works; your bread will remain fresh but not soggy for several days. Yield: One large loaf, about 24 hearty servings.

Additional Notes:
You may use 2 tablespoons pumpernickel, the grain French bakers traditionally add to enhance a bread's keeping qualities, in place of the whole wheat flour in the initial sponge.

For an even chewier bread with larger, more irregular holes, try increasing the amount of water in the dough's second stage by 1/4 to 1/2 cup. Add 1/4 cup initially, then take a look at the dough while it's in its second kneading cycle. Your goal is to create a dough which is very wet and slack, but which will still hold its shape when formed into a freeform loaf. Add additional water if it looks as though the dough can absorb it and still remain firm enough to be workable.

This bread is an ideal candidate for a linen-lined banneton, which will hold and shape it as it rises and, because of the moisture-drawing qualities of the linen, help produce a chewy crust.

Try putting your risen loaf into the oven without slashing it first; it'll develop its own natural split, producing a more rustic-looking loaf.

For a thick, brown, chewy bottom crust, try baking the bread in the oven in a preheated cast iron skillet, or on a baking stone.

For a crisper crust, allow the loaf to cool in the oven. When the bread is done, turn off the oven and crack the door open a couple of inches, leaving the loaf inside.

Just a Hint....
Store crusty hearth loaves uncovered, but with their cut side down on the counter. This is one of the best tips we've come across in some time. Though this doesn't work on baguettes, rolls, or other small loaves, it works beautifully on big boules or freeform loaves. The moisture in the bread's interior gradually migrates to the surface, but since the cut side is covered, it can't escape there; instead, it must navigate its way through the thick crust, a much slower process. This keeps the bread's interior soft, and the crust hard and crunchy.

Nutrition information per serving (1 slice, 1/24 of loaf, 47g): 87 cal, .2g fat, 3g protein, 18g complex carbohydrates, 1g sugar, 1g dietary fiber, 267mg sodium, 38mg potassium, 2RE vitamin A, 1mg iron, 42mg calcium, 27mg phosphorus.


1 23  All  
  • star rating 04/27/2015
  • Rob W. from San Francisco, CA
  • I just made this recipe this weekend and loved it! It turned out perfectly! I could not be happier with the results. I let me sponge ferment a little longer than called for due to my weekend schedule but it still turned out amazingly. The bread is moist, chewy and sturdy with a thick chewy crust and storing the bread cut side down has made it last a few more days that expected. I weighed my flour after converting cups to grams and made sure it was a fluffy moist dough. It was pretty sticky but I didn't add much flour when kneading it to make sure it didn't get too stiff. Tried one loaf with cornmeal on the bottom and one without. The cornmeal on the bottom crust was too crunch on some bites and took away from the wonderful texture of this recipe. Second loaf turned out same as the first. This recipe has given me much encouragement for breadmaking. Next for me is delving into sourdough and maybe a rustic loaf with more whole wheat flour. Thanks King Arthur for not only making great products, but for also providing wonderful recipes for new home bakers.
  • star rating 04/26/2015
  • Tony from Plymouth, Indiana
  • I followed the directions exactly except I used my Kitchenaid stand mixer instead of a bread machine. I used brand new SAF instant yeast. It turned out dense and heavy with a thick, hard crust. I was looking forward to large, irregular holes. What am I doing wrong?
    Tony, we'd love to help you troubleshoot this recipe at the Baker's Hotline. Please give us a call at 855-371-2253 and we can try to help you achieve the nice open crumb you are looking for. Barb@KAF
  • 02/07/2015
  • Dawn from Arizona
  • Not sure how it is going to turn out. 1/4 t of yeast plus 1/4 t of yeast did not allow it to rise :( I had to add the rest of the packet. Any suggestions as to why?

    The recipe calls for instant yeast, which isn't the same as active dry. Active dry yeast needs to be proofed in water before it is able to work its magic. Give the Bakers a call at 1-855-371-2253 if you need more help. Happy baking! Laurie@KAF

  • 12/09/2014
  • Nancy Donahue from Asheville, NC
  • If I do this without a bread machine, do I knead the dough? If so, at what stage?
    You may use a bread machine as the recipe states. The next day after you have made your sponge(or about 8 hours later)continue to make the dough. Program your machine for Manual or Dough. As the dough begins to mix it should form first a soft mass, then eventually a soft ball that is not too stiff, but not sticky, either. Adjust with additional flour or water as necessary. If you need some further assistance please call our Bakers Hotline, 1-855-371-BAKE. Enjoy! Elisabeth@KAF
  • star rating 11/29/2014
  • member-djumatate from KAF Community
  • I love this recipe! This was the second bread recipe I tried, and my first with a poolish, and it always comes out delish. I use my regular oven and I shape it like a batard. Great bread.
  • star rating 10/08/2014
  • Dawn from Stafford, VA
  • I have been making this bead every week for years. I absolutely love it and usually double the recipe to make four loaves. It never fails to please and I love the fact I can make it in stages have have it hang around in a fridge until I have time for next stage. It thrives on neglect. Stale loaves make wonderful French toast and croutons.
  • 09/19/2014
  • stephanie from
  • Question: In the tips at the end of the recipe, it reads "For an even chewier bread with larger, more irregular holes, try increasing the amount of water in the dough's second stage by 1/4 to 1/2 cup. Add 1/4 cup initially, then take a look at the dough while it's in its second kneading cycle." Please explain: I don't see anywhere that 1/4 cup of water is called for (both the sponge and the dough appear to call for 1 cup of water)--so I'm not sure where or how to increase to 1/2 cup.
    The tip indicates that you can add an extra 1/4-1/2 cup water to the dough portion of the recipe. This will be in addition to the cup of water called for. You will want to add 1/4 cup at the beginning of the mix and then if you feel the dough could accept a little more water, add up to 1/4 cup more during the kneading process. Barb@KAF
  • star rating 07/22/2014
  • Anthony from Waxhaw, North Carolina
  • I have made this bread several times, using a wild sourdough starter (,about 3 tablespoons). The bread is as good as one can buy in Europe and I have eaten bread in some 20 countries in Europe. The recipie is excellent .
  • star rating 10/27/2013
  • Sarah from Acton, MA
  • Easy preparation and delicious result. Wonderful chewy crust and light, flavorful interior. I liked that the dough could be made in the bread machine, which allowed a wetter dough (I added the additional 1/4 cup water) than I am able to knead well by hand. I have baked many, many, different recipes of rustic bread with inconsistent results. I am going to make this again right away to see if this recipe produces consistent results. So far so good.
1 23  All