Sourdough Crumpets

star rating (17) rate this recipe »
Recipe photo

Sourdough Crumpets

star rating (17) rate this recipe »
Published prior to 2008

Do you have a long-neglected starter you'd like to resurrect? If you're fortunate enough to have some starter already, you may find in September that you haven't gotten around to using it for more weeks than you'd care to account for. Since it's been sitting there alone, unloved and unfed for so long, it may be looking pretty bleak with a lot of ominous dark liquid on the surface. If you're like me, you probably hoped you'd get around to using it to prevent it from getting to this sorry state, or you certainly would have made a conscious effort to freeze or dry it. But, not to worry. Your starter is probably just fine, though a bit groggy.

The absolutely easiest and fastest (it'll make a mix look like slow motion) thing to do with a groggy starter to see if it's suffering simply from neglect is to make crumpets. Crumpets sound like something you have in England in the afternoon with tea, which they are. But because they are actually a very simple and basic kind of pancake, they're a perfect thing to make with a sourdough starter for breakfast.

Take your starter out of the refrigerator, wrestle the top off your jar and stir all that evil looking liquid back into the starter until it's smooth. For each two people that you'll be feeding, pour 1 cup of starter into a ceramic or glass mixing bowl. Pour the remainder of the starter into another mixing bowl so you can give its container a good washing. Feed the starter in the second bowl equal parts of flour and water, cover it with plastic wrap and watch for tiny tell-tale bubbles to appear on the surface. When you see them, let the starter revive for at least 12 hours before you put it back in the fridge.

To the cup of starter you have in your other bowl, sprinkle over the surface 1 teaspoon of sugar and 1/2 teaspoon each salt and baking soda. Whisk these in thoroughly and watch what happens. Voom! Chemistry at work producing millions of carbon dioxide bubbles to leaven these pancakes.

If you have crumpet rings (about 1 inch high and 4 inches in diameter -- clean tuna cans with tops and bottoms removed will work fine, or you can order some proper rings from us), grease them lightly and place them on a lightly greased spider or skillet. Fill the rings with about 1/4 inch of batter and cook it over low heat until the tops are set and full of holes. Remove the rings and flip the crumpets over for a minute or two.

After they've finished cooking in the skillet, stockpile them and then pop them in the toaster to brown and crisp. Serve them with butter and whatever jam you've put up this season. You can also cool them, bag them, and freeze them to bring out and toast later.

If you don't have rings or cans, you can dispense with the ring idea altogether and cook the batter over slightly higher heat just the way you would pancakes. The texture will be chewier than traditional pancakes and, surprisingly enough, the flavor will not be not overly sour since the baking soda neutralizes the acidity of the starter. The beauty of these pancakes is that they contain no eggs or fat, so you don't have to feel guilty about eating them with a touch of butter and maple syrup.

Taking the pancake idea one step further, the flavor of these crumpets or pancakes, while quite delicious with butter, syrup or jam, is equally good with savory additions. Try adding a half cup each of grated zucchini, cheese, apple, chives or onion, or a combination of your own, and serve them with lunch or dinner.

This recipe reprinted from The Baking Sheet Newsletter, Vol. II, No. 9, September 1991 issue.

Reviews

1 2  All  
  • star rating 05/19/2012
  • Noa from Jerusalem, Israel
  • I have made this recipe before, using my sourdourgh that I have been growing and feeding for the past two years... usually comes out great (my Welsh husband backs me up!) but yesterday, I made the crumpets as usuall, and put them on a rack to cool. Two hours later, I noticed they were a bit greenish. I put them in the fridge, and this morning they were positively green! What did I do wrong? My sourdough has no mold on it, is regularly fed and makes great breads. Help!
  • star rating 05/07/2012
  • sderouen from KAF Community
  • This also works with a rye sourdough starter. It is, of course, much more dense but still good. I always have to add a touch of water to get the baking soda reaction! Thanks again.
  • star rating 03/25/2012
  • sderouen from KAF Community
  • This is an inspired recipe for using the sourdough discard! Mine is a whole wheat sourdough and it was the discard from day 4 of the very beginning of my sourdough journey. I added a 1/2 cup shredded cheese and they were absolutely delicious! It tastes better than an all-purpose flour crumpet recipe I used to make and is faster and easier! Thanks a million!
  • star rating 01/20/2012
  • anyasmifya from KAF Community
  • Simple! A perfect use for all that starter. I always feel bad throwing it away, now I have a use. I added grated cabot jalapeno cheddar to the crumpets. I made them pancake style and they were delicious. I plan on making more for breakfast. Tomorrow I will add a little extra water to the mixture since it was pretty thick.
  • 12/15/2011
  • jackkeller from KAF Community
  • I found this recipe when I searched "revive sourdough starter." I did not have rings and so made them free-form. I buttered them and ate them as pancakes, topped with peach syrup. They were so good that they are now my standard breakfast. I use 1 cup of batter per person and thin the batter a bit so they pour and flatten out more like crepes, about 6-7 inches in diameter. They are so light you expect them to float away. I like them best with coconut syrup but 100% pure maple syrup is a possible tie.
  • star rating 09/12/2010
  • cynthia20932 from KAF Community
  • I've never had a crumpet so I don't know what they're supposed to taste like, but this recipe is delicious. I must have made them too large because I only got 5 and I ate them all. They were pretty light and fluffy. I loved them with butter, but also tried some jalapeno jelly and ginger syrup for fun. Very good.
  • star rating 04/23/2010
  • Linda L. from Campbell, CA
  • My experience with this recipe was an unmitigated disaster. I was excited at having a use for starter so I didn't have to throw it away. The crumpets came out dense, rather than airy. An odd color and an equally odd metallic taste. For me, this is not a keeper.
    We are sorry to hear the recipe was not a success. Please phone or email our bakers hotline and we will be happy to troubleshoot.
  • star rating 03/13/2010
  • Erin R. from Salt Lake City
  • What a great idea! Yummy and easy enough that I will never have to throw my starter away again. I stirred a spoonful of white whole wheat flour into my batter to get it a little less runny, so I suspect I didn't get the usual holey texture, but I did still get some holes and the crumpets were delicious with butter and with blueberry jam. My husband even ate a bunch of these and he doesn't like ANYTHING. I got eleven tuna can-sized crumpets, and could probably have gotten an even dozen if I'd made a couple of them a little thinner. Fantastic little recipe, and you have saved me from the hated wasting of the sourdough. Thanks.
  • star rating 02/10/2010
  • RobynB from Scotts Valley, CA
  • I LOVE this recipe! I poured too much batter into the rings, so mine were pretty thick and had to be cooked until toasted on the outside to make them done inside, but I loved them like that. I split half and put a couple slices of cheese into them and then put them back in the pan for a few minutes, and they were wonderful. It is so great to have a good recipe for unfed starter!!
  • star rating 01/18/2010
  • Lee from Cambridge, MA
  • My starter was on the thick side, so I had to add a little water along with the sugar, baking soda and salt to get the mixture to bubble. I used a cookie scoop to measure out the batter and cooked it pancake-style on a skillet. The results were delicious! A little more savory than a pancake, but lighter and fluffier - perfect with a little homemade strawberry jam.
1 2  All